17 Comments
User's avatar
Ricardo Alberto's avatar

Damn! James had so much more life ahead of him 😪

Expand full comment
Annette Matisz's avatar

Not if he didn’t want to live them :(

Expand full comment
Ricardo Alberto's avatar

True 😞

Expand full comment
Connor McGwire's avatar

Was about to go to bed happy, now I'm sad. 😭 (good sad)

What's particularly funny to me about you posting this now is that I just started reading the book of Tobit for the first time today, and I was struck by a passage with a similar theme of a "redeemed longing for death," where Tobit and a woman both pray for God to end their lives in the face of great suffering. God instead chooses life for them, healing the blindness of the first and bringing a good husband to the other (after her last seven were killed by Asmadeus's meddling) so they can go on to greater works of charity for their fellow Israelites in captivity.

It's a particularly meaningful theme for me.

Expand full comment
Scott Allen's avatar

I wasn’t sure where you were headed when she locked the door behind him, but very effective twist. Powerful ending. Really enjoyed this. Thank you, Kathrine!

Expand full comment
Kathrine Elaine's avatar

Thank you for reading it!🩶 I’m glad you enjoyed it.

Expand full comment
Josh Louis's avatar

What a sad little story. I wonder, if James had a family back home and a reason to live, would he still have done the right thing, even if it put his life on the line? Would he even be in a situation to do the right thing in the first place? Hopefully James finds some peace in his death, or at least an escape from his torment.

Expand full comment
Kathrine Elaine's avatar

You know what? I thought about this story today. Don’t know why. I wrote it a while ago. An interesting coincidence. How did you find it? I thought Substack’s algo ruthlessly swallows older stories, and they don’t really show up anywhere.

Anyway, thank you for reading it. I’m so happy to see my stories are still sparking thoughts.☺️🩶

Expand full comment
Josh Louis's avatar

Just going through old-ish issues of Top in Fiction! You never know when and where someone will encounter your work, and I think that's part of the magic of writing online.

Expand full comment
K.C. Knouse's avatar

Great job of bringing this story full circle. James got what he wanted and saved Hope in the process. We all have a reason to keep living until it's our time to go.

Expand full comment
Kathrine Elaine's avatar

Thank you!

Expand full comment
James Ross's avatar

Yeah, sometimes a character’s fate is sealed. Nothing wrong with James 😉

Expand full comment
James Ross's avatar

I wanted him to live 😔

Expand full comment
Kathrine Elaine's avatar

Me too, but I went along where the story led me. It kinda made sense. Sorry for naming him ‘James’. I just like this name.

Expand full comment
Rosemary Van Gelderen's avatar

So beautiful. I've met James many times. I want to bring them all home but my husband won't let me. I'm happy he died with Hope.

Expand full comment
Feasts and Fables's avatar

Sad/Happy. Brilliant writing.

Expand full comment
Kathrine Elaine's avatar

Thank you…🩶

Expand full comment